HI

... this is an expanding selection of pics and of some of my shorter pieces of writing ... and other bits and pieces ... in German and mainly English ... and other strange languages ... COME BACK AND CHECK IT OUT ... COMMENTS WELCOME

wolfgangsperlich@gmail.com


Thursday, November 19, 2026

THE LAST REVIEW OF GOLIATH’S CURSE BY LUKE KEMP (2026)

 THE LAST REVIEW OF GOLIATH’S CURSE BY LUKE KEMP (2026)

 

Reading Luke Kemps Goliath’s Curse (2026) can be a bit depressing, more so because most of what he says is based on fact. Wading through some 440 pages of dense text, we learn a lot about what should be known by anybody who cares about the future of our planet that seems doomed to collapse by the hands of murderous elites who couldn’t give a damn as long as they make huge profits and elevate their status accordingly. 

 

The long history of societal collapse is a depressing one as it seems that no one ever learns from history, only for rapacious elites to repeat it. It would be farcical (according to Stalin) if it were not for the fact that we are now at the stage of an end game that equals to the extinction of the human species by means of evolutionary suicide.

 

Unfortunately, most reviewers (as cited in the 2026 Penguin edition) cling to the Epilogue of the book which dreams up solutions to the problem:

 

Revolutions begin where myths end; Goliath ends when civilisation begins (p.445).

 

The first part sounds like a fact of the matter to me. Nothing less than a revolution will do. Unfortunately, Kemp provides lots of reasons why this will not happen. Mass surveillance of dissidents by Palantir and associated tech-bros, brutal oppression by police states, obfuscation by the mass media, religious mania, capitalist greed, etc. will kill off any uprisings. We have seen that in the recent youth protests that broke out in France and in many other European states.

 

Revolution will also not happen because there will be no people left to do it: nuclear war, climate disaster, pandemics, caged land, AI and a myriad of deadly branches that Kemp details on his Tree of Doom (p.387). Which brings us to the question: why Goliath? Obviously a clever analogy since we all know the biblical story – or do we? Slaying the evil Goliath seems like a reasonable way out – or is it? Is this an invitation to kill the bad guys? A revolutionary act? Would a successful attempt to kill Hitler have changed history? As Kemp reminds us in his Epilogue, the biblical Goliath was killed by a ‘single slingshot-toting future king by the name of David’ (p.442). In fact, Kemp does not advocate for literally killing Goliath but rather by rendering him impotent by pulling the rug from under him, i.e. way of open democracy, citizens assemblies, juris, workers collectives, equality and voting. Sounds like socialism? Kemp never mentions the word but advises us not to be a ‘dick’ (p.441) and ‘stop arms races, status races and races to the bottom’.  Kemp being an Australian academic cannot help himself using a bit of street language in the desperate hope to reach the people on the street. 

 

One might compare Kemp to that other activist by the name of Tim Winton who in his book Juice (2024) paints a picture of societal collapse due to the climate disaster but with a twist whereby the remaining good guys go after the Goliaths who hide in the underground bunkers (like Peter Thiel will do in New Zealand, as noted by Kemp) and execute them. Winton who recently followed up with a book of essays called Songs from the Firefront (2026) is letting rip, telling his Aussie mates that things are getting worse, not better. It is telling that the so-called liberal Guardian headlines a review of the book with ‘Songs from the Firefront by Tim Winton review – climate urgency verges on panic, with moments of wonder too.’ This guy is creating panic, mate! What a dick! I am sure that Kemp’s invective will rebound on him, what with a phalanx of Goliaths (small and large) taking aim at Kemp for being a doomsday merchant, a latter-day Nostradamus charlatan, a woke ivory-tower academic who gets paid handsomely for writing all sorts of rubbish, a supporter of terror against the divine right of kings and queens, presidents, CEOs and indeed God himself. 

 

Hence despite Kemp’s best efforts to be an optimist in the face of certain doom, we can only commiserate with him on the impossibility of his last idea, namely that ‘civilisation’ begins after we get rid of Goliath (one way or the other). It seems that the history of collapse is a also one of collapse of civilisations if one defines ‘civilisation’ as a system of governance (Latin: civitas, as Kemp is showing off his erudition with various Latin phrases) that is often contrasted with barbarian Untermenschen who have no idea about ‘civilised’ behaviour. Indeed, Kemp’s long chapter on colonialism whereby European colonists used this ruse to oppress and exterminate indigenous peoples around the globe, would give any definition of ‘civilisation’ a bad name. To be ‘civil’ might on rare occasions be a desirable behavioural trait, especially when Kemp tells us about the psychological roots of bad behaviour, namely his ‘dark’ triad of:

 

-              psychopathy

-              narcissism

-              Machiavellianism

 

As someone who did 101 psychology, I’d say that the ‘narcissism’ and ‘Machiavellianism’ are both symptoms of a psychopathy that results in ‘corruption’ (and absolute power results on absolute corruption). So, what then is the root cause of this triad? Is it Moore’s Law of whatever can go wrong will go wrong?  Is it the complexity of human biology that allows for things to go wrong, like pathology in general, like life and death, like nature, like human nature? Is it nurture over nature? Kemp only tells us that we must resist these seemingly primordial traits, as can be seen in some instances by ‘civil societies’ that resist dominance and have instead egalitarian societal structures. He ascribes this especially to the age of the Hunters and Gatherers who worked by consensus to fulfill their daily needs and then spent the rest of the time in peaceful leisurely pursuits. A nice idea, only supported by a lack of archaeological evidence for crushed skulls and mass graves (which in Goliath societies are found by the millions). There might even be some modern examples of egalitarian welfare societies that have minimal governance (but not meaning the libertarian paranoia of ‘big’ or ‘deep’ government’), or at least experimental attempts at non-hierarchical communes (as emerged in the 1960s counterculture, counter establishment movements). Scandinavian countries (not of late though) were often cited as progressive in that sense. The problem here is that even if we believe that altruism is in our genes and that nurture refines it, how come human history so far is mainly based on the selfish gene (not à la Dawkins but à la Lorenz) that is reinforced by nurture (e.g. fascist ideology)? Kemp seems to think that certain developments in human history forced a change of behaviour from good to bad, at least in some individuals.

 

So, going back to more ancient history, Kemp’s theory is that once agriculture is established all hell breaks loose: grains become a lootable resource, and Goliaths move in to steal and plunder. Nevertheless, Kemp scolds Marx & Engels who theorised that ‘surplus’ gave rise to feudalism and capitalism as a precondition for class warfare, and the eventual solution by communism to either abolish any surplus (typically via slave labour) or else distribute it equally amongst the workers who created it (but why would they want to do that?). Kemp notes that the emergence of agriculture was not an evolutionary sine qua non for surplus economies that inevitably gave rise to Goliaths, i.e. in some parts of the world, like New Guinea, large agricultural surpluses were produces but no Goliaths, i.e. no civitas emerged, no states, no empires. Kemp’s main thesis is that any surplus is a lootable resource that tempts dark triad individuals to simply steal and moreover enslave the producers to produce more surplus. Kemp cites the Roman Empire that extracts wealth (slaves and materials) from conquest and keeps the Roman ‘citizen’ populace happy by providing cura annonae (free rations of grains for making bread) and ‘circus’ for entertainment. Kemp spends a lot of pages on the falls of Rome, as famously did Edward Gibbon. After all ancient Rome and Greece are the foundation of Western Civilisation! Kemp goes on to scold the historian Petrarch for bemoaning the fall of fabulously civilised Rome resulting in the dreadful ‘dark ages’. This is contrary to Kemp’s other thesis that societal collapse is not always a disaster. In fact, it can be a blessing in disguise. Ordinary people are at least temporarily relieved of oppression, and they can better fulfill their human potentials. As such all instances of collapse have a silver lining. Even the Black Death was beneficial as it decimated the population, freeing up land for the survivors (a somewhat bizarre notion however factual it is). 

 

Once the (western) Roman Empire has disintegrated into European kingdoms and fiefdoms, we are now on the well-trodden path of history we know so well, from the era of colonisation of the new world to empire building by the British (and others) that fell apart only to be rebuilt by American, Russian and Chinese Goliaths. Kemp concentrates on the Americans as they still command a tenuous hold on world power. A Goliath like Trump with the aid of his billionaire mates has sought to sideline the European powers and make shady deals with the Russians (Putin) and Chinese (Xi). What annoys Kemp most is the ‘revolving door’ whereby high-ranking government officials (ministers, et.) from the defence (war) departments (ministries) and suchlike get top jobs in the associated industries, ensuring minimal governmental oversight – naming names. Well done!

 

There are many a highlight in this book, and I will pick out a few of these pebbles of wisdom. I say ‘pebbles’ instead of ‘pearls’ to avoid elitist language that equates ‘wisdom’ with expensive jewellery. Maybe that’s one omission from the book, namely that we might have to begin to phase out elitist (sexist, racist) language, and while we’re at it, let me give you an example just hot off the press. UN Secretary Gutiérrez at COP31 addresses delegates as ‘your excellencies’ which no doubt they all are, all pretending to be worried about the climate disaster while luxuriating in high-class hotel lobbies and laughing about climate jokes, including the award of the ‘fossil of the day’ to New Zealand, dampening somewhat the clean-green image promoted by the tourism industry (run by former ministers for the environment). As Kemp also notes, Australian climate politics is equally deplorable, if not worse.

 

Back to the pebbles discovered:

 

·      Good on Luke (let’s be informal – non-elitist – and call each other by our first names) to debunk Hobbes in his first chapter (p.21) entitled Hobbes’s Delusion, namely his stupid idea of the social contract whereby the monarch protects the citizens who would otherwise all kill each other.

·      Well done on identifying so-called liberal democracies (especially praiseworthy Scandinavian countries) as essentially democratic hierarchies. Luke quips that even the ancient Athenians would have recognised our current systems not as democracies but as oligarchies (p.75).

·      Studies have shown that ‘gods’ only appeared after large, unequal, hierarchical societies developed. And another nice aside: It makes sense: a hierarchy in heaven justifies a hierarchy on earth (p.128). Obviously, as mentioned above, I would have added Marx’ famous saying that ‘religion is the opium of the people’. 

·      Patriarchy diminishes the male gene pool (p.130). Luke might have mentioned Wilhelm Reich’s contention that the sexual oppression of women (and LGBTQ+)

by an insane combination of patriarchy and religion is the root cause of fascism.

·      The chapter entitled Why Inequality Grows with Lootable Resources (p.134) seems to state the obvious but is nevertheless the mainstay of capitalism. Citing Thomas Piketty, financial returns on capital (land assets, stocks) have outpaced the returns on labour (wages) for at least the past two centuries. That is despite labour requiring more effort and skill than does charging rent on land or betting on stocks.

·      Goliath’s curse is that extractive institutions hold the seeds of their own demise (p.139) which echoes Marx dictum that capitalism makes its own rope to hang itself. Unfortunately, there are always new Goliaths waiting in the wings.

·      There are unsuccessful and successful psychopaths: the latter end up in boardrooms and parliaments (p.166) Indeed! 

·      The US is a superpower in large part because it has the most advanced military force and arsenal of nuclear weapons in the world (p.174). 

·      Collapse rearranges power structures, and the obsolesce of scripts, writing, and language is often just collateral damage (p.201). As a linguist one can only agree and point to the current state of affairs, what with English as the most powerful language in the world. Just imagine a scenario whereby English will be collateral damage (and Mandarin will become the new lingua franca). 

·      Status is inexhaustible, especially when you are surrounded by other ambitious competitors (p.215), cf. Trump and in-fighting of the elites.

·      Once a legitimised hierarchy is deeply rooted in a culture, it becomes hard to remove. Entire systems for justifying inequality are carried forward for thousands of years (p.220). Popular culture in the Western World seems exceptionally well maintained to serve this aim.

·       Diminishing returns of extraction (p.234). From ‘conquest’ as the most profitable method of extraction of wealth down to ‘oligarchic’ systems that struggle to extract wealth from a depressed populace.

·      History has often been a case of eat or be eaten (p.243). Depressing but true!

·      Across history, neither improved technology nor bigger, wealthier empires have resulted in better lives for most of the populace (p.248). Cf. modern technologies aimed at replacing humans.

·      The overall trend is that living standards for most people did not improve dramatically over the long run of history (p.249). In Auckland, New Zealand, where I live, there are staggering numbers of homeless people. The police are given powers to ‘move them on’ (or get arrested) if they annoy much better-off citizens living in mansions in leafy suburbs.

·      One estimate from medieval France (1100-1250) suggests that 20 per cent of (economic) output went to the construction of cathedrals and churches (p.250). It is amazing that millions of tourists admire Notre Dame every year as if it is the height of French culture (which of course it is if we understand culture as a tool of the elites). 

·      There is a great protest song from the 18th century I never knew (p.254):

 

The law locks up the man or woman

Who steals the goose from off the common,

But turns the bigger robber loose

Who steals the common from the goose.

 

·      Even though I studied 101 Latin at university, I just learnt from Luke what the word ‘decimation’ meant originally, i.e. ‘removal of one tenth’ derived from the Roman military punishment for insubordination in which a cohort (around 480 soldiers) was forced to murder a randomly elected tenth of their comrades …. The colonisation of the Americas may have claimed 10-11 per cent of the world’s people at the time (p.256). Decimation indeed!

·      Good on Luke to debunk an example of absolute ‘decimation’ that was blamed on internecine warfare and economic collapse due to the destruction of the environment (deforestation, etc.) perpetuated by the indigenous Polynesian inhabitants of Rapa Nui. Careful DNA analysis shows that the Rapa Nui population had increased until the arrival of the Europeans in the 1860s. “The best-known case of collapse is an example of genocide, not ecocide.” (p268).

·      The whole chapter on Colonisation and Collapse (pp. 259-282) is an excellent one, with many an example (as the one above on Rapa Nui) that clearly shows the scale and absolute brutality of colonisation. One more example is topical as various Caribbean activist currently demand reparations (and apologies) from the British Monarch and his Government, what with both declaring that neither will eventuate. Luke writes: The Caribbean became, in the words of one pre-eminent expert on slavery, ‘a slaughterhouse’. While living, slaves were sometimes branded with ‘DY’ (Duke of York) to designate ownership by the British monarchy (p.279). 

·      When we get to Chapter15 and Collapse in the Modern World, we also get some interesting points of view, e.g. ‘While the Second World Waris often framed as an epic clash between democracies and fascism, it was primarily a conflict over land and people’. Luke argues that the Axis powers had missed out on the scramble for colonies and were now clamouring for Lebensraum. All the main actors, Hitler, Churchill, Rosevelt/Truman and Stalin had scant regard for human life, as for example demonstrated by Churchill’s dismissal of the Bengal Holocaust that killed as many as 3 million Indians. 

·      There might be a bit of irony in Luke’s (correct) observation (p.287) that modern elites share elitist education, i.e. even Kim Jong Un was schooled in Switzerland which seems to hold the monopoly for finishing schools, so, when it comes to elitist university education, one cannot help but note that Luke himself is associated with Cambridge University, one of the grandest in the world. 

·      Speaking of universities, a couple of years ago I presented a paper at an environment-themed conference at the Auckland University of Technology, claiming that human extinction due to the climate disaster is on the cards. Even some of the more liberal academics in the audience scolded me for being overly alarmist and defeatist. I wish I had Luke’s chapter (p.306) on Human Exploitation to Human Extinction Human Extinction on hand to produce the required risk statistics assembled by ‘credible’ Cambridge academics.

·      The multiple disaster scenarios are all interconnected, i.e. even if there is no nuclear war, no climate disaster, no AI end game, there are still many other enormous risks for societal collapse or human extinction. One that occasionally rears its ugly head in the mainstream press is that of the PFAS, the forever chemicals, entirely made by humans ignorant of the consequences. Luke is right to highlight this risk to human existence, given that for example ‘PFAS are now found in the bodies of 97 per cent of Americans’. 

·      A theme that is gaining traction in some quarters but certainly not in mainstream politics and economics is the necessity for de-growth. In New Zealand this is championed by the likes of Mike Joy. Luke puts it like this: ‘Today, this growth fetish underpins our environmental problems (p.344)’. 

·      In Luke’s most unsettling last part of his book entitled appropriately The End Game, he applies a mixed metaphor Mors ex Machina (death by machine, as opposed to the Deus ex Machina) to send us into the abyss. He doesn’t mince his words when he apportions blame: the Goliaths in the shape of a ‘mere handful of giant corporations (mostly headquartered in California), countries and militaries … they are the agents of doom (p.374).  

·      Taking on the ‘giant corporations’ as one of the root causes of impending doom (p.384) we know that in law corporations are given the status of a person, hence the person hiding behind it as CEO always gets off scot-free when corruption and fraud overwhelm the corporation that in this situation takes all the blame personally. Such legal and economic absurdities are being played out on a regular basis, e.g. the current disaster engulfing Jensen Huang, CEO of Nvidia. We are reminded of the earlier quip by Luke in that successful psychopaths are often found amongst the CEOs of the most powerful corporations on earth.

·      So, we pursue the path of evolutionary suicide (p.396) with open eyes, analogous to a ‘cancer’ that destroys its host to destroy itself.

·      And so, in After the Fall (p.408) we are given a few grizzly scenarios of those few who might still inhabit a dying earth, waiting in vain for extraterrestrial saviours, or scrambling to get a lift on Musk’s spaceship to Mars, or reengineering a ‘Second Industrial Revolution ’ (p.412), or getting an invite to live in Peter Thiel’s bunker in New Zealand (p.416), or even succeed in defying the hellish odds and start a new ‘civilisation’ only with ‘Goliath Rebooted’ (p.418). Well, it ain’t gonna happen, not by a long shot, mate!

 

That’s it. The end of the End Game. As mentioned at the beginning of this review, there are a few more pages that Luke dedicates to ‘solutions’, to kill Goliath by means of knowledge, citizens assemblies, open democracy, and workers’ control over production, and voting for the right candidates, and the like. It reminds me of the amusing idea (Galgenhumor) that AI finally figured out that the solution to all our problems is not 42 but socialism via communism (and the dictatorship of the proletariat). Batteries are too low, no juice (to paraphrase Tim Winton): plan cannot be implemented. Goodbye.

 

Well, just enough juice left to tell you the story of how I came to read Luke’s book: our neighbour John heard about this book on his favourite US radio station KPFA.org and he ordered it from the Auckland Library. John’s partner Sharon heard him mention the authors name and subsequently saw a picture of Luke, and to her amazement realized he was her brother’s son who was born and lived overseas, and whom she had never met. Lukes facial likeness was so close to her long-lost brother it was startling. She went to buy the book for John and then saw online that Luke was a speaker at the Auckland Writers Festival that week. She tried to book tickets, but they were sold out. She reached out to Luke via an associated email address, and he was delighted to find his aunty, and he sent her complementary tickets. They got to talk to him at the event and they invited him to come out to their place, and so he did, and they keep in contact. They read the book and then recommended the book to me, and they told me the incredible story how this came about. The rest is history, as they say.

 

https://www.theguardian.com/books/2026/nov/06/songs-from-the-firefront-by-tim-winton-review

 

Monday, November 2, 2026

A journalese review of Barbara Dreaver (2026) Be Brave: The Life of a Pacific Correspondent

 A journalese review of Barbara Dreaver (2026) Be Brave: The Life of a Pacific Correspondent

 

It is probably a good idea to be well informed about what happens in this world. My daily sources of mainstream information are - always carefully reading between the lines - without fail, The Guardian, Der Spiegel, Stuff, RNZ Morning Report and the six o’clock TVNZ1 news. There are also daily summaries in my inbox from The New York Times, and various other left of centre information sources, online and offline, consulted at various times. Most, if not all of this information is produced by journalists, most of them nameless to me, although occasionally I do remember who is who, and sometimes even seek out news articles from them, e.g. George Monbiot from the Guardian who occasionally lets rip without fear or favour. On the TVNZ One 6 o’clock news one gets familiar with the faces and names but one has no choice but to watch them all, just managing to mute the ads in-between. While the news anchors fulfil their role as smiling entertainers without fail, some more enthusiastic than others, the reporters that appear on camera must adjust their acting capabilities to the story at hand: look sad and devastated when reporting on death and destruction, look happy and bemused when reporting on a celebrity wedding. 

 

Journalism no doubt is a craft, first learnt at journalism school and then by doing it. No doubt also, at some stage early on, it is drilled into them that they are the Fourth Estate – at least in so-called Western democracies – with the sole responsibility to hold the other three estates to account. Freedom of the press is a much-vaunted concept that hardly ever lives up to its promise, be it the mainstream press compromised by their corporate owners, or the public broadcasting channels muzzled by the government funders. Now throw into this mix the social media channels, corporate, state-sponsored or influencer-brand-AI-driven – and the occasional individual efforts by bloggers like myself – and you drown in a maelstrom of information and disinformation, only to surface in the ocean of plastic waste. Of course, you may be lucky enough and land in the elysian fields, charmed by all the good news you have just seen on your smart phone. 

 

Having read the accounts by some serious journalists like Fisk and Pilger, I was interested to see how NZ/Aotearoa/Pasifika journalist Barabara Dreaver would stack up with her book entitled Be Brave, suggesting perhaps a courageous attempt at reporting uncomfortable truths. Having come across her when I was working in the Cook Islands as a HOD English at Atiu College in 1992, I was somewhat surprised by the title, as from memory, she was not exactly brave, nor did I have that impression ever since, as she became the preeminent Pacific Correspondent for TVNZ. Reading her book I have somewhat revised my opinion, recognising the occasional acts of bravery even if tinged with naivety. Her student travels in Egypt with a female friend is a case in point. Her friend, a student of Ancient History at Auckland University – while Barbara studied towards a teaching degree – obviously had a fairly good reason to visit Egypt’s ancient sites while Barbara was happy enough to come along (during their OE). Now, in an ideal world there should be absolutely nothing wrong with two young women travelling in Egypt or anywhere in the world, but as we are made to know, this world is hardly ideal. Only the brave make it so - occasionally. As Barbara recounts, they were lucky to escape the male predators that pried on young female tourists. They were lucky but they were brave too. Having myself travelled in Egypt at a more mature age, I can nevertheless attest to the many tourist traps that spoil the beauty of the country and the people – a situation not only true for Egypt but for the rest of the world, in varying degrees. 

 

Dreaver’s chapters on her upbringing in Kiribati and NZ might paint a somewhat exotic picture for Palagi readers who have no idea what the Pacific Islands are all about – barely knowing what NZ/Aotearoa is all about. I emphasise the latter point because the very idea of exotic places on earth is a hugely misleading idea promoted by corporate tourist operators, or worse, by benign racists who romanticise their ideas of white supremacy. Edward Said famously elaborated this state of affairs in his 1978 book Orientalism – a book one might recommend Barbara to read. The postulated otherness of the Pacific Islands and their peoples, especially in relation to New Zealand and Australia, can only be realised as a colonial and post-colonial enterprise. While such issues may seem academic – and we will discuss Scott Hamilton’s review of Dreaver’s book as an academic exercise – they are nevertheless important when it comes to disentangling popular if not populist ideas about the Pacific regions. 

 

It might be telling, therefore, that Dreaver has nothing to say about her academic studies at Auckland university other than not wanting to become a teacher after all. Some three years of study for a BA (in education) must have left some impressions even if one wants to disown them, which in itself would be a fascinating idea worth of self-analysis. Similarly, she brushes off her experiences with not being accepted into the AUT Journalism program but instead into MIT’s 6-months Pasifika Journalism course which she completed top of the class but then could not find a job in New Zealand, being ridiculed by mainstream employers as some sort of inferior coconut course. All of this could have made a couple of serious chapters on NZ racist academia and mainstream media. Maybe by joining the establishment after all makes one less brave.

 

In the meantime, as she writes, the only job she could get was one in the Cook Islands, by invitation of a fellow MIT journalism student, by the name of Jason Brown, born in Australia but presumably brought up in the Cook Islands as he was a student at Tereora College in Rarotonga. They both worked at the Cook Island News. Strangely enough as I just googled Tereora College, as I am writing this, I was directed to an online Cook Island News article entitled ‘Letter: Tereora College ‘on life support’, moaning about ‘Anau’ classes that teach Cook Island Māori indigenous culture instead of concentrating on the more useful NZ English based curriculum. Like Māori in NZ/Aotearoa, Cook Island Māori are at loggerheads with the colonial heritage, one that embraces English-based education and Westminster-style governance. Dreaver could have written a book about it, especially as she studied education. Instead, she details her eight years in Rarotonga as first as a reporter for the conservative, pro-business Cook Islands News and then as an owner/reporter (with Jason Brown) for their Cook Islands Press newspaper. Having become disillusioned with the Cook Island News they set out to expose the various business scams supported and engaged in by the government and business elites, all in the name of battling for the common man who just wants to know the truth – the facts of the matter. The two of them did a very good job at rattling at the corrupt establishment and carpetbaggers who are legend in the Pacific islands. Unfortunately, in my opinion, they never got to grips with the underlying malaise that simply remained in place, giving rise to the next and the next scandal as an inevitable sequence of bad news. When the government goes bankrupt and the NZ/Australian/British donors move in, as they always do when the chips are down, invariably imposing austerity packages for public services, and eventually we resume business as usual. In a small country like the Cook Islands, this merry-go-round cuts across families and traditional alliances shift with the winds of financial opportunity. As such Jason and Barbara – by now partners in more sense than one – swim with the sharks. One might invoke Brecht’s famous lyrics here:

 

And the shark, it has teeth,

And it wears them in the face.

And Macheath, he has a knife,

But the knife can't be seen.

 

In other words, what are the conditions that give rise to Macheath in the Cook Islands (and elsewhere) rather than exposing one gangster after another, as Dreaver seems to do? She never questions the Westminster system which might be unsuitable for the Cook Islands and New Zealand too. Later on, Dreaver also falls for the cliché that China is muscling into the Pacific, being a dangerous presence as harbouring the unmentionable ideology of communism. Her only criticism of the USA in this context is that they are not having a strong enough presence in the Pacific to deter the Chinese. That the Cook Islands as well as the Solomon Islands and Kiribati have been seen as courting the Chinese if only to extract more aid from the Western powers is another thorn in Dreaver’s eyes. Geopolitical analysis is not exactly the forte of many a journalist in New Zealand, instead playing the same old song of the evils of Chinese communism, rather than engaging in a rational analysis that might reveal socialism as a better option for the Pacific (cf. some such attempts as Melanesian Socialism).  

 

This malaise is not only confined to New Zealand as we know all too well. Even liberal British journalists hum along, as for example voiced by a deputy editor from the Guardian, i.e. rubbishing China even as disaster strikes, as in Nepal and Tibet (which is part of China):

 

The challenges posed in covering disasters like this are numerous – from getting reporters like Hannah safely into position as quickly as possible, to assessing and verifying the accuracy of reports coming from scenes of chaos and devastation. The Chinese government’s strict control on information in Tibet makes the challenge even harder.

 

Since Barabara Dreaver is also very much involved in this journalistic disaster enterprise (for the Pacific), describing various political and natural disasters she was sent to report on, we might pause here as well, and expose this rather obscene obsession of ‘getting reporters like Hannah safely into position as quickly as possible’. Forgetting the oxymoron of ‘getting someone safely into a disaster zone’ – not to help but to take pictures of the disaster, one has to wonder what this is all about. Another Guardian correspondent puts it like this:

 

As a war correspondent, I worked with photographers who said the camera was a buffer between them and reality.

 

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/aug/29/sunsets-disasters-dinners-record-phones-camera-reality

 

At the very least, disaster journalists should just do voice-overs instead of being on camera doing dramatic false impressions. Sometimes it may not be the journalist who decides to be on camera but rather the producer who calls the shots. Only once does Dreaver hint at competitive egos clambering for the headline shot – one where Wendy Petrie wants to be the star rather than Barbara – while for the rest it’s always a wonderful team effort, like a happy family doing a great job at delivering the news baby. They all support each other when the inevitable hate mail arrives, as Dreaver quotes some she has received. Obviously, this is a dreadful business carried out nowadays on social media where any crackpot can post abuse and threats. When Dreaver casts herself as an investigative journalist who uncovers scams and conmen, one might assume that abuse comes with the job, just as police get abused by drunks and unhinged members of the public, not to mention the outright criminal fraternity. Maybe Dreaver could do a critique of contemporary NZ society that engenders such abuse rather than promoting the soldierly bravado of BE BRAVE (the title of her book no less). Nobody should have to be brave in the face of abuse and threats. It’s a shameful vision of our society.

 

Barbara Dreaver sees the necessity to offload all this dreadful business a journalist has to contend with, and then bring a bit of levity to bear. This misfires quite badly. When an unnamed fellow journalist (presumably from NZ) at dinner at a watering hole in Rarotonga wants to know how sea cucumbers are grown (as a vegetable) while she tucks in, there is great hilarity about her ‘incredible’ ignorance. Well, really? Sounds rather sad to me. Obviously, there must be lighter moments when journalists (and their camera teams) travel the world, or in this case the Pacific, but do we really want to know all the Schadenfreude? 

 

It is perhaps no surprise that the NZ establishment values Barbara’s commitment to neutral journalism that bows enthusiastically to King Charles and subsequently accepts a gong from the Governor General. This is not to say that Barbara does a rally bad job as a journalist. No, in the overall context she does a not-so-bad job, even if she doesn’t come close to the journalism maxim provided by Bob Woodward as the ‘best obtainable version of the truth possible’.

 

Which brings us to the exercise of applying some proper political analysis as was done by Scott Hamilton when he reviewed Dreaver’s book. As an expert in Tongan affairs, he takes issue with Dreaver’s reporting on the infamous Tongan riots, glossing over the human rights abuses committed by both the Tongan and NZ police:

 

Soon after the riot, with the assistance of the New Zealand police who had flown into the country with Dreaver, Tongan cops began a campaign of retribution and terror that would traumatise a generation of young Tongans. For months young men and women were dragged into Nuku’alofa’s central police station and tortured. I have interviewed half a dozen victims of the terror campaign. All mentioned the complicity of New Zealand police. “Those Kiwi cops would stay for the verbal, then step into the next room as soon as the beatings started,” one told me. “The palangi asked the questions, the Tongans did the hitting.”

                  

Equally Dreaver misrepresents the supposed Tongan democratization in the aftermath as some sort of progressive development:

 

She claims that Tonga became a democracy after the riot, when negotiations supervised with New Zealand saw the constitution rewritten. Tonga’s king, she claims, had “given up power”. After an outburst of inexplicable violence, Tonga was supposedly happily reunited. 

 

Dreaver doesn’t mention that Wellington exerted huge pressure on the pro-democracy movement to agree to a deal that left extensive power with the country’s king. The total inadequacy of the constitutional changes have been shown again and again since they were made in 2010. Tonga’s nobles still have guaranteed seats in the country’s parliament, and its monarch controls the armed forces and has the power to sack ministers and whole governments. In 2024 King Tupou VI used his constitutional powers to sweep away the democratically elected government of Siaosi Sovaleni. 

                  

Hamilton then characterises the general malaise of Dreaver’s Pacific reporting as follows:

 

A comment by Dreaver hints at why she might be so sanguine about Tonga’s continuing lack of democracy, and so lacking in curiosity about its internal fractures. Observing preparations for the burial of King Tupou V, she enthuses about the supposedly “timeless traditions” of the country. Dreaver is fond of that oxymoron ‘timeless traditions’. She also uses it to describe Fiji’s political order. Like many New Zealanders, in this book she appears prone to accepting the nineteenth century Orientalist view of the Pacific as an ancient and unchanging region, a ‘sleepy’ place that contrasts with modern, dynamic Western countries like New Zealand.

 

https://newsroom.co.nz/2026/04/23/book-of-the-week-a-journalists-memoir-part-2/

 

No doubt all correct points raised. Maybe Hamilton expects too much from a mainstream journalist who, despite some academic training at Auckland University, has forsaken academic rigour in favour of a bland concoction of fact and fiction that suits a conservative readership. Since she is now in good company at TVNZ, she may be blissfully unaware as to what goes on in the floors above her. It would not really be an act of bravery if she were to investigate how someone like Paul Henry could be appointed to the Board of TVNZ by Minister Goldsmith – until Henry’s resignation to join the ACT Party as a candidate for the 2026 elections. In her good old days in the Cook Islands, she might have knocked on the Minister’s door and accused him of corruption. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sunday, September 27, 2026

An unlikely review of The Unlikely Doctor by Dr Timoti Te Moke (2025)

 An unlikely review of The Unlikely Doctor by Dr Timoti Te Moke (2025)

 

 

In situations like this I always like to quote Noam Chomsky’s quip that nothing is impossible, but many things are unlikely, although a hard-boiled rationalist might point out that, actually, many things are impossible. Nevertheless, many things are unlikely, as indeed the unlikely doctor is. Timote Te Moke’s moving account of his long journey from oppression and destitution to becoming a doctor is of course an outlier, a statistical anomaly, and yet a reminder that in Aotearoa/New Zealand society, on an individual basis, the seemingly impossible can be achieved – one can foreshadow Te Moke’s eventual realisation that being such an unwanted statistical outlier is due to the injustices of a racist, capitalist system. 

 

Born into dysfunctional family circumstances his first 6 years are saved by being taken care by his loving grandparents. When his Māori mother reclaims him to live with her and his Pakeha stepfather and a younger step-brother, all hell breaks loose. Daily physical and mental abuse – including sexual abuse – drive Timote into the arms of similarly abused boys and girls living on the streets, living of petty crime, being constantly harassed by police, jailed and further driven into the arms of gangs. A life of unimaginable cruelty but a life of streetwise brotherhood with its own codes of sticking together no matter what. Alcohol and drugs turn these youngsters into a potent force of solidarity, and yet, Timote retains a certain reclusiveness that stays with him always. There are rescue attempts by the kind Kayes family whose mission is to save street kids from themselves. Mary Kayes, a teacher, re-instils in Timote a love of reading (which he had acquired during his early primary school age when still in the care of his grandparents) but he is always drawn back into life on the South-Auckland streets, in and out of jail. His most serious offence was throwing a Molotov cocktail in front of a bus – no one was injured.

 

Eventually he has one of these Eureka moments that he describes as thinking ‘this doesn’t have to be this way’ and off he goes, on a whim, to Sydney, a change of scenery undertaken by many a Kiwi bloke who sees no future in Aotearoa. Ending up in Adelaide where he first undergoes rehab with good results, sobering up and getting a good job in a security business. Having done yoga and meditation in rehab, he also does gym workouts to get his body into shape, and he became the ideal security recruit, being able to handle any situation, especially as bouncer in clubs and pubs which unfortunately were not exactly the best environments for a recovering drug addict. He even gets married to the daughter of a pub owner and they have a son, having settled down in a suburban house he had bought. Timote for some reason describes their marriage as ‘toxic’ because they both are too smart – both manipulating each other in ways that are not really addressed. While he dotes on his son, the increasingly violent husband-wife relationship ends in divorce – he having hit her. 

 

Having gained a reputation as a tough security worker who took no nonsense, he was eventually recruited (patched) into a local gang involved in gang warfare, notorious for the Australian scene at the time. Having started his own successful security business and being high up in the hierarchy of his gang, he became one of the number one gangsters in Adelaide, navigating this situation with a mix of business-savvy and bouts of violence. Having been in and around Adelaide myself, I recognised some of the locales described by Timote.

 

One of the telling experiences of that time he describes as not being the usual Australian gangster whose main aim in life, is to get filthy rich, but to splash the dough around like a latter-day Robin Hood, with a memorable line (p.129):

 

                  But I guess you could call me the socialist gangster, the outlaw Karl Marx.

 

An interesting idea but one that could not last. The Australian governments of the day put pressure on the otherwise notoriously corrupt police forces to shut down the gangs by all means, including infiltrating, doing double deals, sort of psych-ops as known these days. This caused Timote untold problems trying to figure out who is who – a skill he had honed to good effect until then. His instinct told him that being trapped in a police under-cover operation was endangering his life. He handed in his patch on the way back to Aotearoa. There is a funny sort of story how he sought to repatriate his money - $10,000 cash at a time – flying back and forth with a cousin courier who freaked out, with the end result that most of Timote’s Australian dollars were left behind. 

 

Being back home he reconnected with his whanau, but more importantly he took an interest in Māori politics, getting involved with the Māori Party, learning te reo, and when his beloved nana dies, he feels like being the surviving link in the long chain of Māori ancestors who had established a honourable culture that was destroyed by the European/British colonisers. Part of his mission was now to resurrect Māori culture and society to its rightful place in Aotearoa. Not that Māori politics are all on the same wavelength, what with internal conflicts that can arise from Waitangi settlements. He describes a few instances when on his marae there was an attempt at a power grab to get hold of the compensation assets. Good on him and his cousins to prevent it. Timote’s renaissance as a Māori activist did however nothing to improve his financial situation. Remembering his days at the Adelaide rehab where yoga and meditation had done him good, he had the interesting idea to enrol in the New Zealand College of Chinese Medicine to study acupuncture. While some Chinese migrants to Aotearoa can be quite dismissive of Māori, there are others who appreciate the ancient history of Chinese-Polynesian connections that emanate from Taiwan – not that Te Moke elaborates on it. Maybe it was just one of these subconscious evolutionary memories that rose to the surface. On the surface too, this was the beginning of a most unlikely journey. Now in his thirties, he had to relearn to study, to read textbooks, pass exams, keep on the straight and narrow, avoiding distractions, temptations, voices from the past. He graduated against all the odds. He travelled from marae to marae to offer acupuncture clinics, a service much appreciated but as it was not covered by ACC, there was no money to be earned from it. 

 

Having gotten a taste of study – it took three years to graduate as an acupuncturist – Timote looked for more opportunities. He found it by searching on the Internet: paramedicine. He enrolled for the three-year degree at AUT but initially wasn’t given permission to do the practicum because he needed a police clearance for it. Even though he had a clean record since his teenage years apart from a minor traffic conviction, he was refused. Only after re-applying he was granted permission. But now start the most traumatic events in his life. Having gotten a part-time student job at the Salvation Army Bridge programme to supervise the residents from midnight to morning, this would lead to a catastrophic event. In 2012 one of the residents had returned drunk, smashed the front door and ran out onto Dominion Road. Timote ran after him. The drunk resident advanced on him. Timote held out the palm of his hand. The resident fell back onto the concrete footpath. He died a week later. Another drunk had been on the scene when ambulance and police arrived. He accused Timote of having punched the other guy. The police charged Timote with manslaughter. All the other sober witnesses denied this had happened. It was on the news. I remember it vaguely, sold as typical violent Maori man punching and killing an innocent Pakeha. His former involvement with the Māori Party was played up in the right-wing press as evidence that the Māori Party too was essentially a terrorist organisation. It took 12 moth to get to trial. AUT had again suspended his permission to do practical ambulance service. His defence layer was totally useless colluding with the police prosecution. Timote had to defend himself. All the evidence pointed to his innocence of merely having defended himself from the drunk’s assault. Even the other drunk who had accused Timoti of punching the guy now admitted not actually having seen Timote hitting the guy. Timote was judged not guilty. In the aftermath it dawned on Timote that the prosecution was in itself a racist attack on Māori, so he raised awareness by first complaining to the IPCA, unsuccessfully of course, and then to the Waitangi Tribunal. The media took an interest, e.g. Māori Television and on a TVNZ programme called I am Innocent. Having gained a national media status was of course not welcome in his job as an ambulance officer – having graduated in the meantime, saying (p.201)

 

                  … while I loved the job I hated the company and the comments I would get.

 

Racist morons would call him a killer on the job. There were complaints from fellow ambulance officers, none of any substance. Te Moke then describes his work as an ambulance officer. It is recommended reading for anyone who wants to take up this profession. The life and death situations faced every day and night require a mental and physical endurance of the highest order. Timote’s life experiences to-date had fortified him, and he was very good at communicating with the patients, being non-judgemental, non-racist, non-sexist – pro-human. Eventually he was frustrated at his inability to treat patients as an ambulance officer with limited medical authority. With an amazing sense of logic Timote decided to apply for medical school.

 

Wanting to enrol at Auckland Medical School he sat the UMAT test, got an interview but was not selected. He tried again next year. He missed out again. So, he tried Otago. As a postgraduate student of paramedicine, he could do a one-year pre-med course and if successful enter medical school for the second year. One had to do chemistry, physics, epidemiology and microbiology, which reminds me of having done the same. As a migrant from Germany, having studied psychology at LMU but not having completed it, I had applied to do pre-med at Otago, with a vague idea of emulating my younger brother who had become a famous surgeon in Germany. Being unaccustomed with the English way of university lectures, I had some problems with physics, and just like Timoti, I was not selected for medical school. I had developed an interest in linguistics instead and eventually I got my PhD at Auckland University. Timoti of course, determined as ever, did not give up his dream of medical school. There was one other pathway to apply: as an applicant that had broad life experiences, skills and perspectives. He received an invitation for an interview. He was accepted. Wow! Off he went to Dunedin. He studied hard. I know from my brother that it is a hard slog, especially for the first three years of mainly theory apart from practical anatomy. In Aotearoa it takes six years to graduate. The last three years are mainly practicum. Timoti did his in Wellington. Given his status as a mature student, now in his 50s, he was confident enough to get through even when the going was tough. He still encountered the odd racist medics and the disbelief of some hospital patients that a Māori could be clever enough to become a doctor. Of course, there had always been an elite of Māori academics but none with his background. He heeded the advice he got from a Rarotongan doctor who perhaps in typical Polynesian fashion had told him to become a doctor, not for personal gain but for the betterment of his community, if not the world. Such lofty ideals are often belittled as disingenuous given the salaries earned by even junior doctors, but then again there are those doctors who do live up to the ideal, at least in degrees. One might quote the Chinese barefoot doctors or the poorly paid Cuban doctors who elevated healthcare not only in Cuba but in South America as well, cf. a medical student called Che Guevara. 

 

A graduated Dr Timote Te Moko applies for a position at Middlemore Hospital, on his home turf. He is accepted at the age of 56. Te Moke ends his book by coming back to his Waitangi Tribunal submission about police treatment of Māori and Pasifika, a slow process that even involved having conversations with Police Commissioners, with the somewhat naïve expectation that even the NZ Police could be part of the solution. Unfortunately, in my view, there is much more at stake than that. Harking back to Timote’s quip about being an ‘outlaw Karl Marx’ and my allusion to Chinese barefoot doctors (and Che Guevara) we need Dr Timote Te Moke to be a die-hard socialist, or even a revolutionary, in order to fulfil his last line (p.271):

 

So I will keep going, creating change in such a way that when it’s time for me to leave the earth, the world will know my name; the world will be a better place because I was there.

 

So what the fuck? In terms of literary criticism, one does understand the book’s inclusion of street lingo of fuck this and fuck that and other such shit, but maybe, just maybe, to make this world a better place one should begin with the use of language. I’ve always liked the tragic comedian Lenny Bruce’s routine of saying that since fuck means to make love, one should say ‘unfuck’ you as an insult (Bruce was arrested many times for obscene language). Te Moke’s liberal use of so-called swear words may well reflect the reality of both lower and upper classes using them in abundance while the polite middle classes pretend not to hear them. Perhaps the newly liberated working classes will use language as a medium of cooperative thought and communication with a rational vocabulary that reflects the Marxist call for ‘workers of the world, unite’.